The Cyber Defense Review

Stabilizing the Borderland: Confronting IO, EW and Cyber in Ukraine

By Dr. Aaron F. Brantly | December 07, 2017

Since 2013 Ukraine has been struggling to maintain its sovereignty in the face of external and internal pressures. Conflict in the eastern portions of Ukraine and the annexation of Crimea placed enormous strain on the capacity of Ukraine to build a stable government and reorient itself towards Europe in the wake of rampant corruption under the previous government of President Viktor Yanukovych. As its very name, Ukrayina, implies it is a country that resides on the border of Europe to the West and Russia to the East, yet it is also a case study in the modern way of war. In June of 2017, four members of the Army Cyber Institute at West Point and the U.S. Army Cyber Center of Excellence at Fort Gordon traveled to Ukraine to assess the usage of cyber, electronic warfare (EW), and information operations (IO). Our report is based on interviews with officials from each agency within Ukraine’s National Security and Defense Council, the security services, armed forces, soldiers from both regular and volunteer battalions who fought on the front lines, as well the leadership of the defense industrial base, academics in its top universities, cyber corporate leaders, and non-governmental organizations. The report provides a detailed and robust look at the challenges Ukraine has faced, the perceptions of those involved in its security, defense, and education, and provides recommendations for future engagements. Our mission was to look beyond the headlines, to delve into the details, and give an unvarnished look at the utilization of cyber, EW, and IO in a hybrid conflict.

Ukraine provides a unique glimpse into the future of warfare. Faced with military, political, economic, and societal vulnerabilities, the tactics of Ukraine’s Russian and Russian backed rebel adversaries highlights the challenges of developing a potent modern fighting force. Ravaged by years of neglect, government corruption, political infighting amongst governmental agencies, and pervasive foreign intelligence penetration, Ukraine’s armed forces and security services have met the most significant challenge the nation has faced in its short history head on and held the line. The conflict has been bloody, technically complex, and psychologically draining, yet despite the challenges faced, Ukraine in coordination with NATO, European Union (EU), United States (US) and Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) assistance has made substantial progress in building the necessary institutions, organizational capacities, human and technical capital. More targeted assistance will be needed in the coming years to bulwark Ukraine against Russian aggression and to create a strong and stable ally.

The conflict in Ukraine is hybrid in form and function. Hybrid war is not total war in a Clausewitzian sense, yet it is pervasive and affects nearly every aspect of Ukrainian society. Ukraine is a nation under siege by a more powerful adversary who allocates resources only in sufficient volume to maintain its siege. To achieve continued conflict at the lowest cost, Ukraine’s adversaries make substantial use of cyber, EW, and IO to achieve, tactical, operational, and strategic advantages. While alone these tools are insufficient to maintain the conflict, they likely reduce its costs and challenge the already financially and organizationally weak Ukrainian security services and armed forces.

It is incumbent upon leaders within the U.S. Army to continually assess and learn from conflict. By examining the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats to the functioning of militaries facing adversaries who incorporate cyber, EW, and IO in combined arms and multi-domain battle environments, we hope to provide Army leaders with a more robust picture of the future of warfare. Understanding the changing character of warfare allows Army leadership to prepare for conflicts left of boom, to adapt training and resources, tactics and strategy to avoid or minimize the challenges faced by others.

The conflict in Ukraine is unlikely to be resolved in the near term, and the utilization of cyber, EW, and IO will likely evolve in the coming months and years. The conflict in Ukraine will remain relevant to the study of the ways and means of war for the foreseeable future.



US Army Comments Policy
If you wish to comment, use the text box below. Army reserves the right to modify this policy at any time.

This is a moderated forum. That means all comments will be reviewed before posting. In addition, we expect that participants will treat each other, as well as our agency and our employees, with respect. We will not post comments that contain abusive or vulgar language, spam, hate speech, personal attacks, violate EEO policy, are offensive to other or similar content. We will not post comments that are spam, are clearly "off topic", promote services or products, infringe copyright protected material, or contain any links that don't contribute to the discussion. Comments that make unsupported accusations will also not be posted. The Army and the Army alone will make a determination as to which comments will be posted. Any references to commercial entities, products, services, or other non-governmental organizations or individuals that remain on the site are provided solely for the information of individuals using this page. These references are not intended to reflect the opinion of the Army, DoD, the United States, or its officers or employees concerning the significance, priority, or importance to be given the referenced entity, product, service, or organization. Such references are not an official or personal endorsement of any product, person, or service, and may not be quoted or reproduced for the purpose of stating or implying Army endorsement or approval of any product, person, or service.

Any comments that report criminal activity including: suicidal behaviour or sexual assault will be reported to appropriate authorities including OSI. This forum is not:

  • This forum is not to be used to report criminal activity. If you have information for law enforcement, please contact OSI or your local police agency.
  • Do not submit unsolicited proposals, or other business ideas or inquiries to this forum. This site is not to be used for contracting or commercial business.
  • This forum may not be used for the submission of any claim, demand, informal or formal complaint, or any other form of legal and/or administrative notice or process, or for the exhaustion of any legal and/or administrative remedy.

Army does not guarantee or warrant that any information posted by individuals on this forum is correct, and disclaims any liability for any loss or damage resulting from reliance on any such information. Army may not be able to verify, does not warrant or guarantee, and assumes no liability for anything posted on this website by any other person. Army does not endorse, support or otherwise promote any private or commercial entity or the information, products or services contained on those websites that may be reached through links on our website.

Members of the media are asked to send questions to the public affairs through their normal channels and to refrain from submitting questions here as comments. Reporter questions will not be posted. We recognize that the Web is a 24/7 medium, and your comments are welcome at any time. However, given the need to manage federal resources, moderating and posting of comments will occur during regular business hours Monday through Friday. Comments submitted after hours or on weekends will be read and posted as early as possible; in most cases, this means the next business day.

For the benefit of robust discussion, we ask that comments remain "on-topic." This means that comments will be posted only as it relates to the topic that is being discussed within the blog post. The views expressed on the site by non-federal commentators do not necessarily reflect the official views of the Army or the Federal Government.

To protect your own privacy and the privacy of others, please do not include personally identifiable information, such as name, Social Security number, DoD ID number, OSI Case number, phone numbers or email addresses in the body of your comment. If you do voluntarily include personally identifiable information in your comment, such as your name, that comment may or may not be posted on the page. If your comment is posted, your name will not be redacted or removed. In no circumstances will comments be posted that contain Social Security numbers, DoD ID numbers, OSI case numbers, addresses, email address or phone numbers. The default for the posting of comments is "anonymous", but if you opt not to, any information, including your login name, may be displayed on our site.

Thank you for taking the time to read this comment policy. We encourage your participation in our discussion and look forward to an active exchange of ideas.